Page 1 of 1

Explaining where data comes from

Posted: 15 Jul 2011 17:08
by RogerF
I would find it useful, when constructing queries and customising column headings (and also for occasional manual edits to the GEDCOM), to be able to relate a piece of displayed data to the internal ways in which that data is identified. Let me try and explain this idea with an example.

In an individual's Property window, there's a pair of fields 'Born ____ in ____'. If I right-click in either of those fields, I currently get a pretty obscure set of choices ('open IME', anyone?). What I'd like to see is an additional choice, let's say 'About this data'. So if I selected that for the birthplace field, FH might tell me some or all of:

- the GEDCOM spec description of this field's purpose

- the GEDCOM storage form, and its approximate location in the file. For example:

   Around line 12345:
   01 BIRT
   02 DATE xxx
   02 PLAC xxx

- the FH way of referring to the data. For example:

   INDI.BIRT.PLAC

- anything else that might be helpful.

ID:5245

Explaining where data comes from

Posted: 15 Jul 2011 17:24
by Jane
The best location to find out about fields is the Columns tab on the Query window which gives you details of every field just select the field and check the bottom of the column for the description.

Those fields are Windows standard ones I think.

I suspect when a gedcom file is loaded in to memory there are no line numbers associated with the data.

On the Customise Property Tab you can already see the Data reference for the field and in most cases you can infer the gedcom structure from that.

Explaining where data comes from

Posted: 06 Aug 2011 12:02
by Jane
Roger, you have not responded on this do you still want it added?

Explaining where data comes from

Posted: 07 Sep 2011 20:15
by RogerF
Yes please, Jane. I'm looking for a set of broader and more consistent data descriptions than the options you mention.

Explaining where data comes from

Posted: 25 Jul 2012 20:34
by Cambiz
WL#495 has been raised for this wish

Please vote for it here:

http://www.fhug.org.uk/wishlist/wldispl ... lwlref=495

Explaining where data comes from

Posted: 25 Jul 2012 22:33
by PeterR
Roger Firth said:
- the FH way of referring to the data. For example:

   INDI.BIRT.PLAC
I have a V5 Plugin which shows all of the data references for any selected record.  I can submit this to the Plugin Store if anyone is interested.