Page 1 of 1
Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 18 Nov 2019 12:21
by Rod Rahman
Hi Everyone
It is likely that I am not the only person who has went to the darkside and started to use a MAC, for computer related life. However I would like to use Historian on my new toy (Macbook Pro), and was hoping that there is someone out there who has been through the same process and challenge.
In light of this can I ask if you have gone through the same transferal, can you advise me on the best, most efficient,. cost effective way of doing this???
All advice and assistance is appreciated.
Thank you in advance,
Rodders
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 18 Nov 2019 13:03
by tatewise
Welcome to the FHUG Rodders.
Yes, there are several Mac users who run both FH and AS successfully and their accumulated knowledge is captured in the Knowledge Base articles listed below.
how_to:family_historian_on_imac_ipad_android_etc|> Family Historian on Mac, Linux, iOS, Android, etc under the Apple Mac section.
In particular the two most popular techniques are:
how_to:family_historian_ancestral_sources_on_oracle_virtualbox|> Family Historian & Ancestral Sources on Oracle VirtualBox which needs a Windows licence.
how_to:family_historian_v6_on_crossover_wine|> Family Historian V6 & Ancestral Sources V5 on Crossover, PlayOnLinux/Mac & Wine which offers some totally free techniques, but with some caveats.
The method of migrating from your current Windows platform to a Mac platform is covered by:
how_to:family_historian_migration_guide|> Family Historian V5 & V6 Migration Guide
Having reviewed those, please post any questions you have.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 18 Nov 2019 13:06
by mjashby
Rodders,
First, there's some advice/guidance here:
https://www.fhug.org.uk/wiki/doku.php?i ... ndroid_etc
On the practicalities, which version of MacOS do you have installed? If it's Catalina (10.15 series) then WINE in it various forms (e.g. Crossover, WineSkin, PlayOnMac) then that is a non-Option at present because of Apple's decision to prevent 32-bit software and system calls from running, which only leaves virtualisation, i.e. running a real Windows OS (Vista, 2007 or later) as a Virtual Machine in side MacOS), or dual booting the Mac (Bootcamp), but that eliminates access to MacOS when running Windows.
Mervyn
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 18 Nov 2019 13:12
by tatewise
There is an update on Crossover for Catalina here:
https://www.codeweavers.com/about/blogs ... s-catalina
They are promising a solution by the end of 2019.
Remember that virtualisation requires a paid for
Windows Vista or later retail licence (an OEM licence won't work).
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 18 Nov 2019 15:59
by mjashby
Have just enrolled in the Crossover 19 beta testing programme and am downloading the newly released beta software for version 19 now (MacOS Catalina compatible). Will report success or otherwise with Family Historian 6 a.s.a.p.
Mervyn
Update Edit: Have now installed the Crossover 19 (beta 1) software and initial testing of Family Historian (an existing Crossover installation) shows 'normal' operation (i.e. as before MacOS 10.15 (Catalina) Upgrade). However a new installation of Ancestral Sources 5 was tried and failed (could not install the required .NET Framework 3.5 SP1 successfully). These initial test results have been provided to the Crossover Development Team.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 08:33
by ShaneB
I'm running FH under Windows 10 and VMWare Fusion on my iMac.
It works for me.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 09:50
by tatewise
Thank you Shane, that works because FH is running in a genuine Windows OS.
But there are significant costs both for VMWare Fusion (£70+) and Windows 10 (£100+) on top of the FH licence.
Thank you Mervyn for that feedback, which sounds promising.
I am not surprised that .NET Framework 3.5 SP1 is a problem, but so much Windows software relies on it that they will probably fix that in due course.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 14:11
by Valkrider
I have just updated my
MacBook with the latest beta of
Crossover. I did not do a reinstall just an update of
Crossover and so far there are no issues with
Family Historian or
Ancestral Sources. This is on
Mojave not
Catalina, my
Air won't run
Catalina as it is too old.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 14:59
by GeneSniper
tatewise wrote: ↑20 Nov 2019 09:50
But there are significant costs both for
VMWare Fusion (£70+) and
Windows 10 (£100+) on top of the
FH licence.
Wow, almost cheaper buying a Windows laptop just to run FH.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 18:59
by Bundle
Encouraging. I've been having FH crashing on me lately. But might try uninstalling and reinstalling and giving it another go. I have a quite modern MacAir with Mojave.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 22:31
by ShaneB
tatewise wrote: ↑20 Nov 2019 09:50
Thank you Shane, that works because
FH is running in a genuine
Windows OS.
But there are significant costs both for
VMWare Fusion (£70+) and
Windows 10 (£100+) on top of the
FH licence.
True, though Windows is a one-off cost, and Fusion is updated only occasionally, admittedly at a not insignificant cost - but I own both products. Crossover (which is new to me) comes with an annual rent which runs out around AUD85 a year, every year. A not insignificant cost either over the medium term.
Swings and roundabouts, I guess.
It's a crying shame that the two best genealogical applications I've encountered (TMG and FH) are both Windoze-only!
All the best
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 20 Nov 2019 22:47
by tatewise
Crossover costs £48 for 1st year of support, and 50% subsequently, i.e. £24 per year for annual renewal.
BUT you don't have to renew and can continue to use that last supported version perpetually.
There is no Windows licence cost.
So if renewed every year it would take 6 years to reach the £170+ outlay on VMWare Fusion and Windows 10 and take even longer if there were VMWare Fusion upgrade costs in that time. That sounds like a good deal.
Alternatively, consider the free Oracle VirtualBox in place of VMWare Fusion and save £70+.
Then you only need the Windows 10 licence cost.
I imagine similar figures would apply for Australian Dollars.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 26 Nov 2019 13:37
by garethhowell
tatewise wrote: ↑20 Nov 2019 09:50
Thank you Shane, that works because
FH is running in a genuine
Windows OS.
But there are significant costs both for
VMWare Fusion (£70+) and
Windows 10 (£100+) on top of the
FH licence.
Even though it's not publicly advertised, it's still possible to upgrade a Windows 7 installation to Windows 10 for nothing. See
https://www.zdnet.com/article/heres-how ... 0-upgrade/. You can get Windows 7 installers for next to nothing.
Sure, it's a bit of a hassle, but that's how I got Windows 10 running inside VMWare on my Mac. Of course, I still had to buy VMWare Fusion.
Gareth
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 26 Nov 2019 14:04
by tatewise
Gareth, that sure is a neat trick, but why buy VMWare Fusion when Oracle VirtualBox is free?
Then the only cost is a cheap Windows 7 licence.
Re: Advice to using Historian on a Macbook Pro
Posted: 26 Nov 2019 18:36
by garethhowell
tatewise wrote: ↑26 Nov 2019 14:04
Gareth, that sure is a neat trick, but why buy
VMWare Fusion when
Oracle VirtualBox is free?
Then the only cost is a cheap
Windows 7 licence.
True. I’ve not tried FH in virtualbox but I have other programs that behaved oddly in virtualbox. True, they involved network communications, but there is quite a trade off with VB. it’s a lot slower than VMWare. Your mileage may vary.